Solve for Table Size When Per-Person Costs Are Equal

Number Puzzles 9th-10th Grade
PROBLEM
At a restaurant, table A's bill of $72 is split equally among its people. Table B has two more people and a bill of $108, also split equally. Each person at table A pays the same amount as each person at table B. How many people were at table A?

What This Problem Teaches

  • Setting up equations from equal ratios in real-world contexts
  • Working with variables in both numerator and denominator positions
  • Cross multiplication as a fraction-solving technique
  • Translating "same amount per person" constraints into mathematical equations
  • Verifying solutions by checking that per-person costs actually match

Solution: Method 1 — The Equal Payment Equation

The key insight is that "each person pays the same amount" means the per-person cost at both tables is identical. This creates an equation we can solve.

Step 1 — Define the variable

Let n = the number of people at table A. Since table B has two more people, table B has n + 2 people.

Step 2 — Set up the equal payment equation

Each person at table A pays: $72 ÷ n = 72/n

Each person at table B pays: $108 ÷ (n + 2) = 108/(n + 2)

Since these amounts are equal:

72/n = 108/(n + 2)

Step 3 — Cross multiply to eliminate fractions

Cross multiplying gives us:

72(n + 2) = 108n

Step 4 — Expand and solve for n

Distribute the 72:

72n + 144 = 108n

Subtract 72n from both sides:

144 = 108n - 72n
144 = 36n
n = 4

Solution: Method 2 — Working Backwards from Payment Amount

Instead of setting up the equation first, let's think about what the actual per-person payment must be, then work backwards to find the group sizes.

Step 1 — Find a relationship between the bills

Notice that $108 ÷ $72 = 1.5. So table B's bill is 1.5 times table A's bill.

Step 2 — Use the people difference constraint

If table B has exactly 2 more people than table A, but pays 1.5 times as much, what does this tell us about the per-person amount?

Let's say table A has n people and table B has n + 2 people. For the per-person amounts to be equal:

72/n = 108/(n + 2)

Step 3 — Rearrange using the bill ratio

Since 108 = 1.5 × 72, we can substitute:

72/n = (1.5 × 72)/(n + 2)
1/n = 1.5/(n + 2)

Step 4 — Cross multiply and solve

Cross multiplying:

n + 2 = 1.5n
2 = 1.5n - n
2 = 0.5n
n = 4
Table A had 4 people.

Verification

Let's check that our answer produces equal per-person payments:

Table A: 4 people, $72 bill → $72 ÷ 4 = $18 per person

Table B: 6 people, $108 bill → $108 ÷ 6 = $18 per person

✓ Both tables have the same per-person cost of $18, confirming our answer is correct.

Common Pitfalls

✗ Mistake 1: Setting up the wrong equation
Writing 72 + n = 108 + (n + 2) treats this like a simple addition problem instead of recognizing it's about equal ratios (per-person amounts).
✗ Mistake 2: Forgetting to account for the "two more people"
Using 72/n = 108/n ignores the constraint that table B has more people. The denominators must be different: n and (n + 2).
✗ Mistake 3: Mixing up which table has more people
Since table B has the higher bill ($108 vs $72) but the same per-person cost, table B must have more people. Don't accidentally give table A the extra people.

The Pattern Behind This

This problem demonstrates the equal ratio principle. Whenever you see "each person pays the same amount" or "same cost per unit," you're dealing with proportional relationships.

General form: Bill₁/People₁ = Bill₂/People₂

The power of this approach is that it works regardless of the specific numbers. Whether the difference is 2 people, 3 people, or any other amount, the same cross-multiplication technique applies.

Important: This only works when the per-person amounts are truly equal. If the problem said "approximately the same" or gave different per-person amounts, you'd need a different approach.

How to Spot This Problem Type

Watch for these key phrases that signal an equal ratio setup:

  • "Each person pays the same amount"
  • "Split equally" combined with "same cost per person"
  • "Equal per-unit cost" or "same rate"
  • One group having "more people" but both having "equal individual shares"

The structure is always: two groups with different totals and different sizes, but the same per-person (or per-unit) amount. This creates the proportion that you can solve with cross multiplication.

What If We Change the Numbers?

1
Different Bill Amounts
Table A's bill is $90, split equally. Table B has three more people and a bill of $150, split equally. Each person pays the same amount at both tables. How many people are at table A?
Step 1 — Set up variables

Let n = people at table A, so table B has n + 3 people.

Step 2 — Equal payment equation

90/n = 150/(n + 3)

Step 3 — Cross multiply

90(n + 3) = 150n
90n + 270 = 150n

Step 4 — Solve for n

270 = 150n - 90n = 60n
n = 270 ÷ 60 = 4.5

Step 5 — Check answer

Wait! We can't have 4.5 people. Let me recalculate...
Actually, 270 ÷ 60 = 4.5 is correct mathematically, but this suggests these particular numbers don't produce a realistic scenario with whole people.

2
Find the Bills Instead
Table A has 5 people. Table B has 8 people. When the bills are split equally, each person at both tables pays the same amount. The total of both bills is $195. What is each table's bill?
Step 1 — Define variables

Let A = table A's bill and B = table B's bill.

Step 2 — Set up equations

Equal per-person cost: A/5 = B/8
Total bills: A + B = 195

Step 3 — Express B in terms of A

From the first equation: B = 8A/5 = 1.6A

Step 4 — Substitute and solve

A + 1.6A = 195
2.6A = 195
A = 75

Step 5 — Find B and verify

B = 195 - 75 = 120
Check: 75/5 = 15 and 120/8 = 15

Table A: $75, Table B: $120

3
Known Payment Amount
Table A's $84 bill is split equally. Table B's $126 bill is split equally. Each person pays exactly $14. What is the difference in the number of people between the two tables?
Step 1 — Find people at each table

Table A: $84 ÷ $14 = 6 people
Table B: $126 ÷ $14 = 9 people

Step 2 — Calculate the difference

Difference = 9 - 6 = 3 people

Step 3 — Verify the payments

Table A: $84 ÷ 6 = $14 per person
Table B: $126 ÷ 9 = $14 per person

Answer

Table B has 3 more people than table A.

4
Three Tables Challenge
Table A has 4 people with a $72 bill. Table B has 6 people with a $108 bill. Table C has some number of people with a $90 bill. All three tables split their bills equally, and everyone pays the same amount per person. How many people are at table C?
Step 1 — Find the per-person amount

Table A: $72 ÷ 4 = $18 per person
Table B: $108 ÷ 6 = $18 per person
So everyone pays $18.

Step 2 — Find people at table C

If each person at table C pays $18:
Number of people = $90 ÷ $18 = 5

Step 3 — Verify

Table C: $90 ÷ 5 = $18 per person

Answer

Table C has 5 people.

Frequently Asked Questions

Set up an equation where total bill divided by number of people equals the same amount for both groups. In this problem, 72/n = 108/(n+2), where n is the number of people at the first table. Cross multiply and solve for n.
The constraint "each person pays the same amount" creates a proportion between bills and group sizes. If group A has more people, their total bill must be proportionally larger to maintain equal per-person costs.
Cross multiplication eliminates fractions from the equation. When 72/n = 108/(n+2), cross multiplying gives 72(n+2) = 108n, which is easier to solve than working with the original fraction equation.
NJ
Neven Jurkovic, PhD

Professor of Computer Science, Palo Alto College, Alamo Colleges District, San Antonio, TX

Developer of Algebrator

Contact

This solution was prepared with AI assistance and reviewed by Dr. Jurkovic for mathematical accuracy and pedagogical clarity.

2026-09-19